CRMuse
CRMuse
customer relationship management
news and analysis
 Topics  
Home
CRMuse Articles (23/0)

 Ads  

 What's New  
STORIES
No new stories

COMMENTS last 48 hrs
No new comments

LINKS last 2 wks
No recent new links


 User Functions  
Username:

Password:

Don't have an account yet? Sign up as a New User

 Older Stories  
Monday 14-Mar
  • Government CRM, and the Birth of a Nation (errr... Website) (22)

  • Sunday 13-Mar
  • Five Questions With Jim Dickie (20)

  • Thursday 10-Mar
  • My Three Weeks in Telecom: A CRM Insider's Nightmare (22)

  • Wednesday 09-Mar
  • Incentives R Around, Pi R Squared (and Other Math Jokes) (24)

  • Tuesday 08-Mar
  • Predictive Dialers, We Need To Talk (23)

  • Monday 07-Mar
  • Where Is the CRM Love Of My Life? (23)
  • Who Are You, and What Are You Doing Here? (22)


  •  Advertisers: Try To Tell Us Something We Don't Know    
     Author:  jcompton
     Dated:  Thursday, March 17 2005 @ 11:46 PM EST
    CRMuse ArticlesI don't envy the job of the modern advertising executive. So many of the obvious functions of advertising have been, for lack of a better word, outsourced to the marketplace—usually involuntarily. After all, advertising, and marketing in general, exists in part to provide potential and current customers with information, preferably that leads to a sale or continued business, or occasionally to stave off trouble.

    But with so many people (whether for pay, as a hobby, or both) in all forms of media constantly looking to break news of new product and service developments, the "new product" side of the house isn't the same game anymore. As for spinning the quality and suitability of a product or service for a given customer, that's still important—but again, that omnipresent media is ever more saturated by customer advocates looking to give their opinions and evaluations of those same products. We already know that Crest helps fight cavities, that milk provides calcium, and that Dell will sell you a PC and then answer the phone when you call about it. We get it.

    Advertisers of the world, I implore you and urge you: try to tell us something we don't know. Because I'm seeing a distressing trend, and it's at best not terribly convincing and at worst uncompelling and insulting.

    Increasingly, advertising seems to be about damage control. I'm not talking about direct, to-the-point damage control, such as doing a reasonably honest job of standing up and taking blame for trouble. In one of the more boring ads aired since the advent of color television, Jacques Nasser, then the CEO of Ford Motor, sat in his office and said he was sorry about the Firestone tire trouble. I'm less troubled by the fact that, clearly, he didn't have much choice left but to take public responsibility than I was at the fact that he wasn't long for the job after that, but that, as they say, is life at the top.

    No, I'm referring to banks and phone companies telling us just how much they care not about numbers, but about people. This notion is both fairly easily dispelled if one has ever done business with a bank or phone company, as well as more than a little troubling, since in fact we would like them to care a whole lot about numbers and let us get on with our own personal lives on our own time. As others have done a better job deconstructing the ridiculous Citibank ads than I can in this space, I'll leave it at that.

    I'm referring to HMOs advertising the merit and expertise of their nurses. This is fine, until you come to realize that it's not about giving the nurses a pat on the back so much as it is trying to lay the groundwork for customer acceptance of a nurse as a primary care provider, taking those pesky expensive MDs out of the acute (and chronic?) health care process as much as possible. And I'm referring to eBay's "power of all of us" ad campaign, which talks about how wonderful it is that eBay works because, on the whole, everybody's trustworthy. My gut reaction to this campaign was "Huh. eBay must be having a real fraud problem lately."

    Advertising at its best is equivalent to one friend telling another how important they are to one another and how there's something that could make the relationship even better. Sadly, faced with all the challenges of marketing in the 21st century, it seems to be devolving into a naughty three year old insisting that absolutely nothing at all is broken in the room they just left.


    None of the companies mentioned in this article have been clients of CRMuse LLC or Jason Compton for at least the past six months.



     What's Related  

     Story Options  
  • Mail Story to a Friend
  • Printable Story Format


  • Advertisers: Try To Tell Us Something We Don't Know | 1 comments | Create New Account
    This site claims no responsibility for posted comments. And we will turn them off if they become a big problem.
    Advertisers: Try To Tell Us Something We Don't Know
    Authored by: JGillespie on Friday, March 18 2005 @ 03:04 PM EST
    What's even worse about the whole mess is that the 'three year old' mindset behind the marketing is a result of a lot of businesses practicing the same philosophy. 'We didn't do that! Nuh uh!'